© Ja Crispy / Shutterstock.com
If you own iShares iBoxx $ High Yield Corporate Bond ETF (NYSEARCA:HYG), you own the largest, most liquid way to rent out cash to junk-rated companies. HYG tracks the broad iBoxx USD Liquid High Yield Index, pays monthly, and holds $15.84 billion in assets. A smaller fund built around a credit-market quirk has, over the same decade, out-yielded and out-returned HYG while charging roughly half the fee.
That fund is the VanEck Fallen Angel High Yield Bond ETF (NASDAQ:ANGL), a $3.08 billion portfolio of bonds issued as investment grade and later downgraded to junk.
Where HYG Falls Short
The broad universe of high-yield corporate debt is what this fund’s index buys. It comes with two frictions. First, the fee: HYG carries a 0.49% expense ratio. Second, its benchmark treats every junk bond the same, with no built-in mechanism to lean into forced selling, which is where fallen angels earn their reputation.
Over the last ten years, HYG delivered a total return of 57.35%, roughly 4.65% annualized. Its trailing 12-month distributions total $4.706921 per share, a yield of about 5.93% on the current $79.30 price.
The Forced-Seller Mechanic
When a bond gets downgraded from investment grade to high yield, investment-grade index funds, insurance portfolios, and pension mandates are contractually required to sell without regard to price. That forced selling pushes the downgraded bond to a discount, often right before it enters the high-yield index.
The ICE US Fallen Angel High Yield 10% Constrained Index is the benchmark for this fund, which buys those bonds after the technical selling and holds them as the discount unwinds. The result is a portfolio of larger, older, formerly blue-chip issuers: Nissan Motor, Vodafone, Paramount Global, Whirlpool, VF Corp, and similar names that fell out of investment grade rather than companies born as junk. ANGL’s focus on fallen angels gives it a distinct profile compared to the broad high-yield market.
What the Edge Looks Like in Numbers
Over the past decade, ANGL returned 75.04% on a total-return basis versus HYG’s 57.35%. Annualized, that is roughly 5.85% for ANGL against 4.65% for HYG, a gap of more than a full point per year compounded for ten years. On $10,000 invested, that is thousands of dollars in outcome.
Income tells the same story. ANGL’s trailing 12-month distributions total $1.8767 per share on a current price of $28.90, working out to a yield of 6.50%. That is 179 basis points above the 10-year Treasury at 4.71%, and roughly 60 basis points above HYG’s yield. ANGL charges a 0.25% expense ratio, about half of HYG’s 0.49%.
The Tradeoffs
This fund doesn’t win every window. Over the last five years, HYG’s total return of 18.85% beat ANGL’s 14.90%, or roughly 3.58% annualized versus 2.90%. Fallen angels have longer duration than the broad junk market, so when rates rise (as they have, with the 10-year climbing from 3.97% in February to 4.71% now), ANGL feels it more. Over one year, ANGL is ahead at 5.33% versus HYG’s 4.44%, but the five-year gap is a real reminder that this is still a credit product with rate sensitivity.
Both funds hold junk-rated debt, so default risk is real, and a recession will hurt ANGL’s larger, cyclical names (autos, retail, telecom) just as it hurts HYG’s broader book.
How to Think About the Swap
In a tax-advantaged account, moving from HYG to ANGL is close to costless. In a taxable account, check the embedded gain first, since high-yield ETFs generate ordinary-income distributions and capital gains on sale are taxable. A partial swap, say half the position, captures most of the fee and yield edge while preserving HYG’s shorter duration as ballast if rates keep rising.
What to Do With This
If your reason for owning HYG is high-yield income at low cost, ANGL delivers more of both, with a decade of total-return outperformance to back it up. If your reason is minimum duration or maximum liquidity, HYG’s $15.84 billion asset base still has an edge. Weigh the yield and fee gap against the five-year rate-driven wobble, and size the swap to your own tolerance for duration.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.